We are reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn a commission. Learn more about our review process.

Nerdy Science in the Kitchen

Best Margarita Mix for Your Machine



So many great options!
So many great options!

If you’ve been thinking of hosting a get-together that needs a simple cocktail, you probably will be pleasantly surprised with how easy it can be to make large batches of frozen margaritas when you use a machine. Once you find the perfect margarita mix for the machine, you’ll be well on your way to hosting one of the most memorable parties.

I’m sure that many people would love to have their frozen margaritas hand-crafted and blended to order. If you’re hosting a large party, this is probably not feasible or sensible. There’s absolutely no shame in selecting a margarita mix that tastes great and mixes up well when used with a margarita machine.

How do I choose a margarita mix?

Selecting a flavor or margarita mix is mainly a matter of personal preference. There are a few factors to consider when making your decisions on which mix will be best for your gathering.

You’ll need to know how many guests will be consuming margaritas and then determine how many margaritas they’ll each be drinking. Are your margaritas are especially delicious and go down smoothly? Then you should definitely plan on making a few more than you had initially planned.

If you own or are considering renting a margarita machine, chances are that you intend on making a large number of margaritas for an upcoming party. Maybe it’s just your regular Saturday night, but I’m not here to judge. Choosing a margarita mix for a machine is not too different from choosing a mix for making margaritas by hand. However, you’ll want to select a flavor that holds up well to being watered down.

Check out the Ninja Master Prep at Amazon

Ninja 400-Watt Blender/Food Processor for Frozen Blending, Chopping and Food Prep with 48-Ounce Pitcher and 16-Ounce Chopper Bowl (QB900B), Silver

View on Amazon

A margarita machine makes the tedious task of mixing together margaritas by hand and then blending them a thing of the past. By adding the specified proportions of ice, margarita mix, and tequila, the machine does a majority of the work for you by pulverizing the ice into a deliciously frosty base in which the margarita mix and tequila reside.

Make ice for dozens of drinks in minutes with the best ice machine for your home bar!

Why should I use margarita mix?

Strawberry, anyone?
Strawberry, anyone?

Utilizing a margarita mix will save you both time and money if you were also considering making all of your margaritas by hand. Even if you were to buy all the separate ingredients, investing in a margarita mix will be more cost efficient and less taxing to take home from the store. If you could consolidate several ingredients down into one easy bottle, wouldn’t you prefer that?

Margarita mixes are perfect to use when you know you won’t be able to take the time to carefully blend and mix each guest a margarita for their sipping pleasure. As the host of the party, it’s important to mingle and connect with your guests. You don’t want to constantly be whirring the blender in hopes of keeping everyone topped off! Using a mix means you can enjoy a delicious margarita while also enjoying the company of your friends and family.

Assuming that you have the tequila and ice situation under control, you’re going to need a high-quality margarita mix to complement your tequila. We’re not looking for ultra sugary and thick mixes. What we need is a mix that hits all the important flavor profiles for which margaritas are known.

What’s the best margarita mix for a machine?

A traditional margarita starts with tequila as its base and usually triple sec as the accompanying liquor. If you do not have this on hand, be sure that your margarita mix has a citrusy orange flavor.

Snappy Frosti Tropics Mix & Match Slush & Slushy Mix, 6 Pack

Snappy Frosti Tropics Mix & Match Slush & Slushy Mix, 6 Pack

View on Amazon

Other important flavors are tart lime juice tartness and a little sweet and sour syrup to ensure the flavor isn’t overly tart. Oftentimes, you can find pre-made margarita mixes with other additional flavors added like mango or strawberry.

Check out this two-pack of Tres Agaves Organic Margarita Mix at Amazon

Tres Agaves Organic Margarita Mix 1L (Pack of 2)

View on Amazon

Many commercially-sold margarita mixes are made with an unnecessary amount of sugar and preservatives to prolong shelf life. Although these can be delicious, opt for a higher quality margarita mix for your gathering. A high-quality margarita mix will make delicious frozen margaritas without leaving you with the dreaded sugar headache.

Check out Fat Mama’s “Knock-You-Naked” Margarita Mix at Amazon

Fat Mama's "Knock-You-Naked" Margarita Mix

View on Amazon

Try to envision how the mix will taste when watered down a bit from the ice as you shop. Mixes for machines are usually super concentrated and should not lose a lot of flavor once diluted.

When life gives you limes, make margaritas!

Regardless of the flavor profile you prefer, always be sure to buy a little more than you think you’ll need. Many margarita mixes come in smaller and larger sizes to accommodate your specific needs. You can even purchase a gallon of certain mixes at a lower unit price. If you know you’ll use it, this is more economical than purchasing several smaller bottles.

Thinking of getting a new machine? Check out my review of the best margarita machine for your home.

You know what else makes an awesome party drink? Mojitos! Here’s the best muddler.

Frozen drinks would go nicely with some frozen dessert! Read my review on snow cone machines for your home.


Kitchen Professor author
About the Author: Rose Reinhard

Rose Reinhard is a Thai-American foodie from Chiang Mai, Thailand. She's been a creative writer since she could speak and enjoys making vegetarian/vegan dishes and reading about food science. She claims her air-fryer is the best purchase she’s ever made to date.

Leave a Comment