We are reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn a commission. Learn more about our review process.

Nerdy Science in the Kitchen

Best Knife to Carve Prime Rib



man's hands using knife and fork to cut prime rib
What’s the best knife to use to cut prime rub?

When it comes to kitchen tools, there is only one that needs to be as good as you can afford, and that’s your “go-to” knife. You may have a substantial knife collection filling up a drawer, or a nice set in a block, but you almost certainly have a favorite. I’m talking about the knife that gets a little more care and attention than the others when the rest of the knives aren’t looking.

Best Knife to Carve Prime RibWhy We Like It
1. Victorinox 12-Inch Granton Edge Slicing Knife with Fibrox Handle ice tempered edge will keep this knife sharp for years
2. Ontario 7111 Old Hickory Butcher Knife affordable but excellent knife made in the USA
3. Wusthof 4519-1/36-100 Gourmet 14-inch Brisket Slicer Shun’s model is made with quality, high-carbon stainless steel

Prime rib basics

The word “perfection” is probably used a lot more in cooking than in any other discipline. When it comes to meat, however, this superlative can be unashamedly applied to prime rib. (The very name of it suggests as much.) It is not very difficult to cook up amazing prime rib. Pick up some high-quality beef, use a generous application of good salt, and get your pan nice and hot. Whether you intend on serving your prime rib “burnt” or “bloody,” you should prepare it as follows.

First, find the oldest, most marbled, and dry aged beef you can get your little hands on. Leave the bright pink meat for the less experienced chefs. What you want is super flavorful and (almost funky) smelly beef! If you don’t have a decent butcher in your town or city, and the guy behind the meat counter at your local supermarket doesn’t know where to find one, I would suggest moving to somewhere that does. This is serious business.

Let the meat relax for a few hours outside of the refrigerator to ensure an even cook. While a very cold fridge may be great for a refreshing drink, it also brings meat to close to freezing temperature. There’s no point in asking whether guests want their meat well-done or rare if you’re left with a raw center between blackened edges (which pleases no one).

Cooking meat might not be rocket science, but it is chemistry. Salt the cut liberally and seal using a very high heat. This triggers the caramelization of proteins near the surface (the Maillard reaction), which imparts a standout color and a rich, deep flavor.

Look for an aged and well-marbled cut for spectacular prime rib.
Look for an aged and well-marbled cut for spectacular prime rib.

Carving time!

To properly carve prime rib, you want a quality, sharp knife. Carving knives come in many shapes and sizes, but the best ones all have a few things in common—they will made from high-grade metals and be very sharp. A 10 to 12 inch blade with a uniform edge should do the job just fine.

Always hone and oil the blade before and after each use to ensure many years of slicing and dicing.

Which models are the best?

Let’s look at a few different brands for portioning up some exquisite pieces of meat for your guests.

The Victorinox 12-Inch Granton Edge Slicing Knife with Fibrox Handle deserves a mention. It features a high-carbon stainless steel blade that’s ideal for slicing through any rib. Its ice-tempered edge will keep it cutting cleanly for many years. The patented Fibrox handle guarantees you won’t slip around too much either. You only have five fingers on each hand so, if you are not a math whiz, you may wish to keep all of them.

Ontario also make some very good knives that are perfectly suited to carving up prime rib. Their 7111 Old Hickory Butcher Knife is a very good example of this. This model is designed and made in the USA, but comes with a price tag that is more akin to something mass-produced overseas. This is a great knife that you can easily afford and be proud to own.

14" Brisket Slicer, Hollow Edge

My favorite knife for prime rib is the Wusthof 4519-1/36-100 Gourmet 14-inch Brisket Slicer. It might be five times the price of the Ontario, but I have rarely heard anyone complain about paying too much for a knife that they genuinely enjoy using. The ABS polymer handle stands up to very high heat, and the length of the cutting edge will let you carve up even the largest of prime ribs.

View on Amazon

Visit this post to see the best sharpener for Wusthof knives.

Primed for prime rib!

With a great knife in hand, you’ll have everything you need to carve up succulent smoked or sous vide prime rib on your next date night. Serve it up with a side of mashed potatoes and a freshly-uncorked bottle of wine, and treat your lady to a romantic evening. (If you picked up an expensive model, maybe she’ll be impressed enough to overlook the price.)

Still curious about knives? See our comprehensive guide on the best knife sharpeners to learn how to care for your most important kitchen utensil.

Want to carve a brisket next? Here are the best knives for the job.

Kitchen Professor author
About the Author: Bryce Heitman

Bryce is not a real professor, but he's real nerdy in the kitchen. He's been barbecuing, chopping, and generally blazing food for many decades. He thinks there's definitely a better spatula or utensil out there that hasn't been invented yet.

Leave a Comment