What’s the Best Cookie Press for Making Cheese Straws

Want to save big time on all your shopping? Try Amazon Prime 30-Day Free Trial
Cheese straws go great with soup and salad!

Cheese straws go great with soup and salad!

A cookie press is a cylindrical tool with a plunger on one end and a hole on the other. The plunger pushes cookie dough out from the hole. At the end with the hole, various interchangeable perforated plates with different shaped openings can be attached.

This is so that the dough is pushed out in distinctive shapes, much like those Playdough sets children use. As cookies are even more popular during the holiday period, common examples include a star, Christmas tree, or snowflake shape.

Cheese Straws…Huh?

Cheese straws are a tasty pastry snack made from a light, flaky pastry and cheese. They make for a great entrée to accompany soup at a dinner party, or simply as a delicious little snack to keep you going throughout the day. Don’t overdo it though, as they’re not the healthiest things you could snack on!

Did those pastries go right to your hips? Learn about the best mason jars for juicing and smoothies for healthy life!

Cheese straws are versatile in that there’s no singular recipe for making them. Everyone wants to put their own stamp on the cheese straw. I’ve come across blue cheese straws, Parmesan cheese straws, jalapeño white cheddar cheese straws, and many more. They go great with a soup or salad. Whether you prefer wafers chopped into smaller slices, or the more traditional method of putting the dough through a cookie press, they’re a delight and worth celebrating.

Avoid moldy or dried out cheese with these methods on how to store cheese in the refrigerator.

Sounds great, but how do I make them?

To make cheese straws to go through the cookie press, you will need:

  • Softened butter
  • A 1 lb block of sharp cheddar
  • Salt
  • Ground red pepper
  • Paprika
  • All-purpose flour.

Shred the cheese, and then mix the butter, cheese, salt, pepper and paprika into a delicious paste. You should mix them gently but thoroughly in a mixing bowl. Gradually add the flour, stirring it in as you go. You’ll be left with a lovely, cheesy dough.

Select the opening shape of your choice for the dough press. Stars are very popular, but if it’s December you might want to go for the Christmas tree. Press the dough through the cookie press to make long ribbons, which you will then cut into shorter strips. Follow the instructions of the manufacturer of the cookie press to ensure you use it correctly. Otherwise, you might ruin your cheese straws, and that would be a disaster!

Head on over here for my recommendations on the best cookie sheets for convection ovens!

Bake your strips on some baking paper in the oven at 350° F for about 10 minutes, or until they are nicely browned. Once you’re satisfied that they are baked to your liking, chill them on a wire rack for 30 minutes or so. Serve your cheese straws alongside a nice bowl of tomato and basil soup, or in a nice salad.

Check out some great soup recipes that will help you get over even the most stubborn winter cold!

What should I look for in a cookie press?

Cookie presses often come with disks in lots of fun shapes!

Cookie presses often come with disks in lots of fun shapes!

Like all tools with moving parts, ease-of-use and durability are important. If the dough, for example, is a little thick, greater force will be necessary to force it out. Will the handle withstand this pressure, or will it snap off, rendering your press useless? Going cheap might leave you with a less durable cookie press.

Other features can make the experience more satisfying, including how easy is it to wash, how many different attachments are included, how easily it dispenses the dough, and a number of other considerations.

The Best Cookie Presses for Cheese Straws

OXO Good Grips Cookie Press

The OXO Good Grips Cookie Press is a popular choice among seasoned cheese straw makers. The non-slip base keeps the press steady on your countertop when in use. This helps to keep the cheese straws neat and uniform. The long handle provides greater leverage to dispense the dough, and the clear cylinder allows you to see exactly how much dough has been used. It features 12 different stainless steel disks in various patterns to suit the seasons. They come in a neat compact storage case, so you won’t lose them about the kitchen.

See the OXO Good Grips Cookie Press on Amazon


Wilton Cookie Pro Ultra II Cookie Press

A slightly cheaper cookie press is the Wilton Cookie Pro Ultra II. It has most of the same features as the OXO device, including non-slip base and a transparent cylinder. This model comes with a greater selection of cookie designs, but does not have the convenient storage case. Instead of pushing the handle down, you pull it up, as if pulling a trigger on a water hose.

See the Wilton Cookie Pro Ultra II Cookie Press on Amazon


The DKST Kitchen Press

The DKST Kitchen Press is a fantastic option, though a little more expensive. The stainless steel press is larger than most on the market, and it’s very sturdy. This big cookie press produces a lot of cookies or cheese straws. Its robust design means that it can handle a tougher dough than most. Plus, it comes with 25 designer disks and a miniature recipe book!

See the DKST Kitchen’s Spritz Dough Cookie Gun Kit on Amazon

Although it doesn’t have the transparent cylinder, it does have everything else. For those willing to spend a little more, this press usually retails at the high end of the spectrum.

Spritz Cookie Press Kit by Virtuous

For a cheaper alternative, I recommend the Spritz Cookie Press Kit by Virtuous. This model has a stainless steel design without a transparent cylinder. That does make it harder to monitor how much dough is left, but the steel body is durable. The kit comes with 20 cookie disks and a biscuit machine, meaning you can use it for more than just cheese straws.

See the Virtuous Spritz Cookie Press Kit on Amazon

This press costs is economical and comes with a lifetime warranty.

Marcato Deluxe Biscuit Maker

The Marcato Deluxe Biscuit Maker is another great cookie press for cheese straw making. Don’t worry about the name! It’s manufactured by an  Italian company, and cookies are called biscuits in Europe. The Marcato Deluxe is very much a cookie press. It comes with 20 different metal templates for creating your own designer cheese straws. The handle will also unscrew from the tube for easy cleaning.

See the Marcato Deluxe Biscuit Maker on Amazon

Despite not being an American brand, it’s a really good cookie press.

C is for cookies…and cheese!

If cheese straw making is new to you, but something you feel you might enjoy and want to pursue, you should consider getting a cookie press. However, there are a number of things you need to consider. How much are you willing to spend? How will it look in your kitchen? Will you use it for other things, like cookies? Check out the models on this list and see which one is right for you!

Love yogurt?  Here’s how long your favorite ingredient will last outside the fridge.

Did you like this post? You might also want to read about the best cookie press for spritz cookies. Then read about the 6 ice cream scoops that will have you baking cookies like a pro!

For roll-out cookies, see the best rolling pins for cookie dough!

Are you a baking fanatic? Find out how to fill delicious cupcakes, choose a springform pan for baking cheesecake, and more on The Kitchen Professor!

Image credit via Flickr Creative Commons: gkrew and Windell O.